View Bug Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0002537||DCP-o-matic||Bugs||public||2023-05-26 18:47||2023-06-03 15:01|
|Platform||Mac||OS||OS X||OS Version||10.14|
|Summary||0002537: MainMarkers in Interop DCP|
Have just made an Interop DCP with DOM 2.16.55 (not tested in 2.16.56 yet, but don't see anything related in changelog) on Mac OS 10.14.6.
The CPL comes out with
First reel: FFOC with offset 1
It strikes me these aren't very useful markers, as they don't convey any information beyond "it starts at the start, and ends at the end"!
The odd thing is that when outputting Interop, the "Markers" button is greyed out, so there's no way to set useful markers e.g. for start of end credits. But there's also no way to disable the FFOC/LFOC markers.
Something similar was discussed before (https://www.dcpomatic.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=1834) but it's unclear to me from that discussion what the upshot was.
Are markers meant to be included in Interop DCPs? If so:
|Tags||No tags attached.|
|Estimated weeks required|
|Estimated work required||Undecided|
I think we probably just shouldn't write them to interop. The FFOC/LFOC thing is the same in SMPTE, and Bv2.1 defines what values they have (1 and length-1) which is odd, to put it politely!
Interop markers removed in 86b88c37c34de9cd0c51e0825d28b6258e2451d2 for 2.16.57.
|2023-05-26 18:47||overlookmotel||New Bug|
|2023-05-28 18:44||carl||Note Added: 0005698|
|2023-05-28 19:59||carl||Branch||=> 2537-markers|
|2023-05-28 19:59||carl||Estimated work required||=> Undecided|
|2023-05-28 19:59||carl||Assigned To||=> carl|
|2023-05-28 19:59||carl||Status||new => confirmed|
|2023-05-28 19:59||carl||Target Version||=> 2.16.57|
|2023-05-29 21:48||carl||Status||confirmed => resolved|
|2023-05-29 21:48||carl||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2023-05-29 21:48||carl||Note Added: 0005704|
|2023-06-03 15:01||overlookmotel||Note Added: 0005728|